Race and Membership

Eugenics in Germany:   "Where is This Path Taking Us?"



"Where is this path taking us and where should the boundary line be established?"1
-- --Else von Löwis, a supporter of the Nazi party, 1940


Overview
Germany did not become a "racial state" all at once. The change took place step-by-step, decree-by-decree. Each new policy went a little further than those enacted earlier. At each step, the German people had to make choices.

In November of 1940, Else von Löwis, a Nazi supporter, was troubled when she learned that the government was murdering the inmates at a nearby mental institution. She expressed her concerns in a letter to a friend, the wife of the chief justice of Germany's Supreme Court:

Undoubtedly you know about the measure now used by us to dispose of incurable insane persons; still, perhaps you do not fully realize the manner and scope of this, nor the horror it creates in people's minds! … On the occasion of our last business meeting at the Gau School in Stuttgart, about the middle of October, I was still told by a "well-informed" person that this involved only idiots, strictly speaking, and that application of "euthanasia" applied only to cases which have been thoroughly tested. It is entirely impossible now to make anybody believe that version, and individual cases established with absolute certainty spring up like mushrooms. …

The most awful thing in the present case is "the public secret" which creates a feeling of uneasiness. … Those who are responsible for those measures, have no concept of the measure of confidence they have thereby destroyed. Everybody must at once ask: What then can still be believed? Where is this path taking us and where should the boundary line be established?2

The judge's wife gave the letter to her husband, who forwarded it to the Nazi leadership with assurances of von Löwis's loyalty. In response, the facility near von Löwis's home was closed, but the murders continued elsewhere. In May 1941 Clemens Graf von Galen, the Catholic bishop of Munster, spoke out against euthanasia for the first time.

Else von Löwis and the bishop were not the only Germans who faced difficult choices in regard to the mass murder of the disabled, Jews, and others considered a threat to the Hitler's "racial state."

Click here to view other choices German individuals made.





Speaking Out
In May 1941, "eugenic" questionnaires were sent to homes for the elderly. Soon after, Clemens Graf von Galen, the bishop of Munster, asked his congregation, "Do you or I have the right to live only as long as we are productive?" If so, he argued, "Then someone has only to order a secret decree that the measures tried out on the mentally ill be extended to other 'nonproductive' people, that it can be used on those incurably ill with a lung disease, on those weakened by aging, on those disabled at work, on severely wounded soldiers. Then not a one of us is sure anymore of his life." His sermon was secretly reproduced and distributed throughout Germany, as was a pastoral letter he wrote to church members. Aware of Galen's popularity, Hitler responded by announcing the closing of the euthanasia program. In fact, it was not closed. It continued secretly throughout the war and may have claimed 100,000 more lives.3








1   Quoted in By Trust Betrayed: Patients, Physicians, and the License to Kill in the Third Reich by Hugh Gregory Gallagher (Holt Publishing) 1990, p. 155.
2   Ibid., pp. 154-155.
3   Quoted in For the Soul of the People by Victoria Barnett (Oxford University Press) 1992, p. 164.

Copyright ©2002-2010 Facing History and Ourselves




Facing History Resources
Race and Membership in American History: The Eugenics Movement (Facing History and Ourselves National Foundation, Inc., Brookline, Massachusetts) 2002, Chapter 8, "The Nazi Connection."

Facing History and Ourselves: Holocaust and Human Behavior (Facing History and Ourselves National Foundation, Inc., Brookline, Massachusetts) 1994, Chapter 8, "Bystanders and Rescuers."



Print and Video Resources
The Third Reich: A New History by Michael Burleigh (Hill and Wang) 2000.

By Trust Betrayed: Patients, Physicians, and the License to Kill in the Third Reich by Hugh Gregory Gallagher (Holt Publishing) 1990.

In the Shadow of Death: Living Outside the Gates of Mauthausen by Gordon I. Horwitz (The Free Press) 1990.

The Nazi Connection: Eugenics, American Racism, and German National Socialism by Stefan Kühl (Oxford University Press, New York) Chapter 2, 1994.

Racial Hygiene: Medicine Under the Nazis by Robert N. Proctor (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts) 1988.

• Video: In the Shadow of the Third Reich: Nazi Medicine (54 min., source: Movies Unlimited).